Customer Center

Find all the information you need to Pay Your Bill, File a Claim, or Check Your Accounts. Simply use the drop down list below to select your carrier to get the necessary contact information.

Can’t find what you are looking for? Give us a call – 845-778-1000

Select your carrier:


Website: www.encompassinsurance.com

Access Your Account: Log in to myEncompass

File a Claim: Find a Claim Office

Make a Payment: Log in to myEncompass


Website: www.libertymutual.com
Telephone: 1-866-681-9325

Access Your Account: Log in to Liberty Mutual

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Liberty Mutual


Website: www.msagroup.com

File a Claim: File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to MSA


Website: www.nationwide.com
Telephone: 1-877-669-6877

Access Your Account: Log in to Nationwide

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Nationwide


Website: www.nycm.com
Telephone: 1-800-234-6926

Access Your Account: Log in to NYCM

File a Claim: 1-800-234-6926 OR Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to NYCM


Website: www.phly.com
Telephone: 1-877-438-7459

Access Your Account: Log in to Philadelphia

File a Claim: 1-800-765-9749 OR Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Philadelphia


Website: www.preferredmutual.com
Telephone: 1-800-333-7642

Access Your Account: Log in to Preferred Mutual

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Preferred Mutual


Website: www.progressive.com
Telephone: 1-855-758-0630

Access Your Account: Log in to Progressive

File a Claim: 1-800-274-4499 OR Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Progressive


Website: www.thehartford.com
Telephone: 1-860-547-5000

Access Your Consumer Account: Log in to The Hartford
Access Your Business Account: Log in to The Hartford

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim


Website: www.safeco.com
Telephone: 1-800-332-3226

Access Your Consumer Account: Log in to SafeCo

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to SafeCo


Website: www.selective.com
Telephone: 1-866-332-6482

Access Your Consumer Account: Log in to Selective

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Selective


Website: www.sterlingins.com
Telephone: 800-462-4661

Access Your Account: Log in to Sterling

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Sterling


Website: www.travelers.com
Telephone: 1-800-842-5075

Access Your Consumer Account: Log in to Travelers
Access Your Business Account: Log in to Travelers

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Travelers


Website: /www.uticanational.com
Telephone: 1-800-274-1914

Access Your Account: Log in to Utica National

File a Claim: Log in to File a Claim

Make a Payment: Log in to Utica National

Contact Us

70 Oak Street, Walden, NY 12586
Monday – Friday: 9am to 4pm

845-778-0100

About Us

Hunter Insurance is an Independent Agent that works with many carriers, which means we can shop around on your behalf to ensure you are getting the best coverage for your needs.

Savings without sacrifice.